Case Analysis for Oil Spills

Topics: Petroleum, Report, Oil spill Pages: 4 (1336 words) Published: May 17, 2013
Engineering Ethics

Case Analysis and Action Proposal

Oil Spills

Students: Fatima Al Khouri 100020247
Hind Al Muhairi 1000020268

Instructor: Dr. Jorge
Submission Date: Wednesday October 17th, 2012

Case Summary
Peter has been working for with the Bigness Oil Company's local affiliate and established a trusting relationship with Jesse, manager of the local facility. Jesse was pleased with Peter's work and recommended that he be retained as the corporate consulting engineer. One day, Jesse started telling Peter a story of a mysterious loss in one of the raw petrochemicals he receives by pipeline in the 1950's. Since there was no surface or groundwater pollution off the plant property, the plant manager decided to do nothing and not report the states. Tests showed that there is zero concentration of gasoline in the groundwater within 400ft of the surface. Peter recognizes that the state law requires him to report all spills but doesn’t know about spills that happened a long time ago. He tried to convince Jesse that he has to report such a loss. However Jesse refuses and told him that reporting will not do the company, peter's career and the environment any good. Jesse also noted that, Peter's own Engineering code of ethics requires confidentiality and he can't have a consulting engineer that doesn’t value client loyalty.

"What?" - Situation
There are several facts issued through the issue that have different levels of importance. The oil spill happened a long time ago in the 1950 and it stayed in a vertical plume and slowly diffused into a deep aquifer. The surface water and 400 feet deep into the groundwater there was zero gasoline concentration. The state law acquires reporting all spills, however the plant manager decided to do nothing. Peter and Jesse agree on the facts but disagree about...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Analysis of Exxon Valdez Oil Spill Essay
  • Oil Spills Essay
  • Oil Spills Essay
  • oil spill Essay
  • Oil Spill Essay
  • Oil Spills Essay
  • Essay about Oil Spills
  • First Solar Powered Case: An Analysis Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free
More Details | Lotions & Oil | Kamisama Hajimemashita: Kako-hen